As much as a third of the AI supply chain receives no attention from national and international policymaking and regulation, according to a new Cambridge report that reveals a vast “zone of invisibility” in the middle of global AI production.
A University of Cambridge team found vulnerabilities across 14 supply-chain layers, with 137 elements produced or convened in over fifty countries. Many critical “chokepoints” sit outside the AI powerhouses of China and the US.
“The US and China are central to the AI story, but this research shows us the extent to which critical technologies and materials across the AI stack have dependencies that extend far beyond their borders,” said Verity Harding, Director of the AI and Geopolitics (AIxGEO) project. “It shows that no one country can control the AI supply chain alone.”
One Japanese firm has a 95% market share of a material needed for AI chips, the report shows. Even notorious chokepoints depend on other nations: the Dutch firm dominating EUV lithography (ASML) relies on essential parts controlled by German and US companies.
In fact, the study suggests that countries such as Japan, Germany, and some so-called middle powers – from Belgium to South Korea – have far more leverage over global AI production than even their own governments realise.
Researchers describe an “unexpected mismatch” between a nation’s top AI policy documents and its actual positions in the supply chain, calling it a “universal pattern”.
“Most policy discussions reduce artificial intelligence to just a few inputs, such as compute, data and models. This is not an accurate understanding of the complexity of the AI supply chain,” said lead author Dr Siyi Liu.
“Many governments are unaware of the strengths and vulnerabilities they hold at the heart of the global AI supply chain. Understanding this will be the basis of credible bargaining power in AI governance,” Liu said.
“Many governments hold more cards than they realise”
Verity Harding, Director of AIxGEO
The UK is involved in 41 of the 137 supply-chain elements researchers identify, yet its AI policies name just three, ignoring UK specialisms in chip design and industrial gases. Japan is second only to the US in terms of supply-chain positions, yet its AI policy documents recognise only three.
Researchers analysed 117 AI-related policy documents from 43 countries, the EU and OECD. They found a fixation on models and datacentres, as well as funding and governance, while the factories, chemicals, chip-design software and packaging technologies vital to the AI supply chain are completely overlooked.
Disruption to any one of these “upstream” components could trigger a domino effect that leads to AI supply shortages, potentially destabilising stock markets, investment and productivity around the world.
Experts from AIxGEO at Cambridge’s Bennett School of Public Policy say that total “AI sovereignty”, a nation autonomously operating its own AI supply chain – a goal many nations hint at pursuing – is “impossible”.
The research team created a toolkit for governments to audit their place in the chain. They say it will help policymakers understand where and when to diversify across AI element providers, who they depend on, or when to “exit” entirely from an outside supplier and build national capacity.
Leave a comment